Which voting system is fairest?: a maths EPQ idea
A title to start from
Which voting system is fairest? Testing first past the post against the alternatives
Why it works as an EPQ
Arrow's theorem says no system is perfect, so you must choose criteria and weigh trade-offs, which is the heart of an EPQ.
Scope and difficulty
Solid. Solid. Three systems, three criteria, simulated and real elections.
The maths
Builds on these A Level topics: Probability · Proof.
You would learn:
- Preference profiles
- Fairness criteria
- Arrow's impossibility theorem (statement)
One possible plan
- Define three systems and run them on small examples.
- Choose fairness criteria and test each system.
- Simulate elections and measure how often each criterion fails.
- Reach a reasoned verdict.
Pitfalls
- Party-political argument instead of analysis.
- Claiming to prove Arrow's theorem.
Where to start reading
- Search for: Arrow's impossibility theorem simple explanation
- Search for: Condorcet paradox example
Frequently asked questions
Is this a good maths EPQ idea?
It can be. We rate it Solid: it needs some new maths learned on your own. Three systems, three criteria, simulated and real elections.
What maths does this EPQ use?
It builds on these A Level topics: Probability; Proof. You would learn: Preference profiles; Fairness criteria; Arrow's impossibility theorem (statement).
Next step
Turn this idea into your own title, then check it in two minutes.
Check your titleSimilar ideas
- Game theory and cooperationCan game theory explain why rival firms or countries fail to cooperate?
- What a student loan really costsHow much will a student loan really cost? Modelling repayments over a working life
- How inflation is measuredHow is inflation measured, and does the official figure reflect what students actually spend?
- Pricing an option with probabilityHow can probability put a fair price on a financial option?
All maths in economics, finance and society ideas · all 93 ideas
Your EPQ must be your own work. How to use help and AI honestly.