Why a piano cannot be perfectly in tune: a maths EPQ idea
A title to start from
Why can't a piano be perfectly in tune? Equal temperament versus just intonation
Why it works as an EPQ
Frequency ratios, powers of 2 and logarithms explain a compromise every musician lives with.
Scope and difficulty
Solid. Solid. Ratios and logarithms; recordings or a tuner app for evidence.
The maths
Builds on these A Level topics: Exponentials and logarithms · Sequences and series · Algebra and functions.
You would learn:
- Frequency ratios of intervals
- Cents and logarithms
- The Pythagorean comma
One possible plan
- Build a scale from 3:2 fifths and show it does not close.
- Calculate the size of the gap.
- Compare equal temperament with just intervals in cents.
- Judge the compromise, with listening tests if possible.
Pitfalls
- Claims about how intervals 'feel' with no evidence.
- Confusing frequency ratios and differences.
Where to start reading
- Music: A Mathematical Offering (Dave Benson)
- Search for: Pythagorean comma cents
Making something? Read the artefact guide first.
Frequently asked questions
Is this a good maths EPQ idea?
It can be. We rate it Solid: it needs some new maths learned on your own. Ratios and logarithms; recordings or a tuner app for evidence.
What maths does this EPQ use?
It builds on these A Level topics: Exponentials and logarithms; Sequences and series; Algebra and functions. You would learn: Frequency ratios of intervals; Cents and logarithms; The Pythagorean comma.
Next step
Turn this idea into your own title, then check it in two minutes.
Check your titleSimilar ideas
- Why instruments sound differentWhy do a violin and a flute playing the same note sound different? Fourier analysis and timbre
- Perspective in Renaissance artHow did Renaissance artists use geometry to create perspective, and how accurate were they?
- Tilings and EscherWhich shapes can tile the plane, and how can symmetry be used to design an original Escher-style tiling?
- Predicting race timesCan you predict a marathon time from a 5 km race? Testing a power-law formula
All maths in music, art and sport ideas · all 93 ideas
Your EPQ must be your own work. How to use help and AI honestly.