Skip to main content

Statistics and data · Ambitious · Dissertation

P-values and the replication crisis: a maths EPQ idea

A title to start from

Why do so many published results fail to replicate, and how much is the p-value to blame?

Make it your own, then check your title.

Why it works as an EPQ

Hypothesis testing is on the course; seeing how it is misused is a serious and current question.

Scope and difficulty

Ambitious. Ambitious. Use simulation to show the effects rather than surveying all of science.

The maths

Builds on these A Level topics: Hypothesis testing · Statistical distributions · Sampling and data.

You would learn:

One possible plan

  1. Simulate many small studies of a true null and of a small real effect.
  2. Show how selective reporting inflates false positives and effect sizes.
  3. Compare remedies (pre-registration, larger samples, corrections).
  4. Judge whether p-values are the problem or how they are used.

Pitfalls

Where to start reading

Real data for this idea

  1. Primary source: OSF (Open Science Framework): Reproducibility Project: Psychology. The project's data files give original and replication effect sizes and p-values for 100 studies. Licence: Varies by project.

Links checked October 2026; we link to the data and never copy it. More free data sets.

How to reference these.

Frequently asked questions

Is this a good maths EPQ idea?

It can be. We rate it Ambitious: it suits students happy to read first-year university material. Use simulation to show the effects rather than surveying all of science.

What maths does this EPQ use?

It builds on these A Level topics: Hypothesis testing; Statistical distributions; Sampling and data. You would learn: Type I and II errors and power; Multiple testing; Publication bias.

Next step

Turn this idea into your own title, then check it in two minutes.

Check your title

Plan your timeline · How it is marked · Dissertation structure

Revising A Level Maths too? A free account saves your practice and progress. Join free · Sign in

Similar ideas

All statistics and data ideas · all 93 ideas

Your EPQ must be your own work. How to use help and AI honestly.

The Extended Project Qualification is offered by several awarding bodies, including AQA, Pearson Edexcel, OCR and WJEC/Eduqas. A Level Math Revision is independent and is not affiliated with or endorsed by any awarding body or university. Summaries of the rules are in our own words: your school and your board's specification have the final say. Every idea here is our own.