Is maths discovered or invented?: a maths EPQ idea
A title to start from
Is mathematics discovered or invented? Weighing Platonism against formalism
Why it works as an EPQ
A classic question that becomes an EPQ when every claim is tested against real mathematical examples.
Scope and difficulty
Solid. Solid. Two positions, three or four worked examples, a reasoned verdict.
The maths
Builds on these A Level topics: Proof.
You would learn:
- Platonism, formalism and intuitionism
- Non-Euclidean geometry as a test case
- Imaginary numbers as a test case
One possible plan
- Set out the main positions fairly.
- Choose examples that each position explains well or badly.
- Work through the mathematics of each example.
- Reach a judgement and answer the strongest objection.
Pitfalls
- An essay with no mathematics in it.
- Strawman versions of a position.
Where to start reading
- The Mathematical Experience (Philip Davis and Reuben Hersh)
- Mathematics: A Very Short Introduction (Timothy Gowers)
Frequently asked questions
Is this a good maths EPQ idea?
It can be. We rate it Solid: it needs some new maths learned on your own. Two positions, three or four worked examples, a reasoned verdict.
What maths does this EPQ use?
It builds on these A Level topics: Proof. You would learn: Platonism, formalism and intuitionism; Non-Euclidean geometry as a test case; Imaginary numbers as a test case.
Next step
Turn this idea into your own title, then check it in two minutes.
Check your titleSimilar ideas
- Maths and the breaking of EnigmaHow much did mathematics contribute to breaking Enigma, compared with other factors?
- Newton or Leibniz?Newton or Leibniz: who deserves credit for calculus, and did the dispute hold British mathematics back?
- How zero became a numberWhy did it take so long for zero to be accepted as a number?
- What Gödel really provedWhat do Gödel's incompleteness theorems really show about the limits of mathematics?
All history and philosophy of maths ideas · all 93 ideas
Your EPQ must be your own work. How to use help and AI honestly.