Home › International A Level › IAL P2 › Exam questions › Proof
IAL P2 proof: exam questions with mark schemes
Proof by deduction, proof by exhaustion and disproof by counter-example, in number, algebra, inequalities and coordinate geometry (proof by contradiction is P4).
Each question carries its marks, and its mark scheme sits under it: M marks for method, A marks for accuracy, B marks for a correct result on its own. Try the question on paper first, then open the solution and mark yourself the way an examiner would.
Edexcel IAL P2 Pure Mathematics 2 · 5 questions · 17 marks · Disproof by counter-example, Proof by deduction, Coordinate geometry
Question 1
2 marks · warm-up
Show, by means of a counter-example, that the statement
“if x 2 > 9 , then x > 3 ”
is not true for all real numbers x .
Show solution
Chooses a value of x with x < − 3 , e.g. x = − 4 M1
( − 4 ) 2 = 16 > 9 but − 4 < 3 , so the statement is false A1
Note: any x < − 3 earns both marks.
Answer: e.g. x = − 4 : x 2 = 16 > 9 but x = − 4 < 3 .
Question 2
3 marks · standard
Prove that one more than the product of two consecutive even numbers is always a square number.
Show solution
Consecutive even numbers written as 2 n and 2 n + 2 , where n is an integer B1
2 n ( 2 n + 2 ) + 1 = 4 n 2 + 4 n + 1 M1
= ( 2 n + 1 ) 2 , the square of an integer, so always a square number A1 (cso)
Answer: 2 n ( 2 n + 2 ) + 1 = 4 n 2 + 4 n + 1 = ( 2 n + 1 ) 2 .
Question 3
3 marks · standard
Show, by means of a counter-example, that the following statement is false.
“For all non-zero real numbers a and b , if a > b then 1 a < 1 b . ”
Show solution
Chooses a and b of opposite signs with a > b , e.g. a = 1 , b = − 1 M1
1 a = 1 and 1 b = − 1 A1
1 > − 1 , so 1 a > 1 b and the statement is false A1
Note: the statement is true when a and b have the same sign, so a correct counter-example must have a > 0 > b .
Answer: e.g. a = 1 , b = − 1 : a > b but 1 a = 1 > − 1 = 1 b .
Question 4
4 marks · harder
The points A ( 1 , 2 ) , B ( 7 , 4 ) , C ( 9 , 10 ) and D ( 3 , 8 ) are the vertices of the quadrilateral A B C D .
Prove that A B C D is a rhombus but not a square.
Show solution
Finds the lengths of the four sides, e.g. A B = 6 2 + 2 2 M1
A B = B C = C D = D A = 40 , so A B C D is a rhombus A1
Tests for a right angle, e.g. gradient A B = 1 3 , gradient B C = 3 M1
1 3 × 3 = 1 ≠ − 1 , so A B is not perpendicular to B C : not a square A1 (cso)
Answer: All sides 40 ; m A B × m B C = 1 ≠ − 1 , so no right angle.
Question 5
5 marks · harder
(a) Show that the statement
“n 2 + 3 n + 5 is never a multiple of 3 for positive integers n ”
is false. [2]
(b) Prove that n 2 + 3 n + 5 is odd for every integer n . [3]
Show solution
(a) n = 1 : 1 + 3 + 5 = 9 M1
9 = 3 × 3 is a multiple of 3 , so the statement is false A1
(b) n 2 + 3 n = n ( n + 3 ) M1
If n is even, n ( n + 3 ) is even; if n is odd, n + 3 is even, so n ( n + 3 ) is even A1
So n 2 + 3 n + 5 is even + 5 , which is odd, for every integer n A1 (cso)
Alternative for (b): n = 2 k gives 4 k 2 + 6 k + 5 = 2 ( 2 k 2 + 3 k + 2 ) + 1 ; n = 2 k + 1 gives 4 k 2 + 10 k + 9 = 2 ( 2 k 2 + 5 k + 4 ) + 1 (M1 one case, A1 both cases, A1 conclusion).
Answer: (a) n = 1 : 9 = 3 × 3 . (b) n 2 + 3 n = n ( n + 3 ) is even (one of n , n + 3 is even), so n 2 + 3 n + 5 is odd.