Exam-style questionsCorrelation Hypothesis Testing questions with mark schemes
Easiest first. Try each question on paper, then open its mark scheme: M marks are for method, A marks for accurate answers that follow from the method, B marks for independent results.
Question 1easy3 marksYear 13
A teacher records, for a random sample of 12 students, the number of hours spent revising and the mark in a mock exam. The product moment correlation coefficient is \(r = 0.62\). The critical value for a one-tailed test at the 5% level with \(n = 12\) is 0.4973.
(a) Test, at the 5% level of significance, whether there is evidence of positive correlation between revision time and mock mark. (3)
Mark scheme and answer
(a) \(H_0: \rho = 0\), \(H_1: \rho \gt 0\) B1
\(0.62 \gt 0.4973\) so reject \(H_0\) M1
There is evidence of positive correlation between hours revising and mock exam mark A1
Answer: Reject H0: evidence of positive correlation
Board notes: Hypotheses must be in terms of \(\rho\), the population correlation coefficient. Edexcel papers print the critical value table in the formula booklet; AQA and OCR usually give the critical value or p-value in the question. OCR may ask for the test to be "carried out" with the p-value supplied from software.
Question 2easy3 marksYear 13
A sample of 30 students gives a PMCC of 0.29 between hours of sleep the night before an exam and exam score. The critical value for a one-tailed test at the 5% level is 0.3061.
(a) Write down suitable hypotheses for a test of whether more sleep is associated with higher scores. (2)
(b) State the conclusion of the test. (1)
Mark scheme and answer
(a) \(H_0:\rho=0\), \(H_1:\rho\gt 0\) B1
\(\rho\) is the population PMCC between hours of sleep and exam score B1
(b) \(0.29 \lt 0.3061\): not significant; insufficient evidence of positive correlation between sleep and exam score B1
Answer: (a) H0: ρ = 0, H1: ρ > 0; (b) not significant
Board notes: Hypotheses must be in terms of \(\rho\), the population correlation coefficient. Edexcel papers print the critical value table in the formula booklet; AQA and OCR usually give the critical value or p-value in the question. OCR may ask for the test to be "carried out" with the p-value supplied from software.
Question 3medium5 marksYear 13
For a random sample of 20 towns, the product moment correlation coefficient between the average house price and the percentage of residents aged over 65 is \(-0.41\). For \(n = 20\), the critical values for the PMCC are: 5% one-tailed 0.3783; 2.5% one-tailed 0.4438; 1% one-tailed 0.5155.
(a) Test, at the 5% level of significance, whether there is any correlation between these two variables. (4)
(b) State, with a reason, how your conclusion would differ if the test had been for negative correlation at the 5% level. (1)
Mark scheme and answer
(a) \(H_0:\rho=0\), \(H_1:\rho\ne0\) B1
Two-tailed 5% so critical value \(\pm0.4438\) M1
\(|-0.41| \lt 0.4438\), do not reject \(H_0\) A1
Insufficient evidence of correlation between house price and percentage aged over 65 A1
(b) One-tailed critical value \(-0.3783\); \(-0.41 \lt -0.3783\) so there would be evidence of negative correlation B1
Answer: (a) not significant – no evidence of correlation; (b) would be significant: evidence of negative correlation
Board notes: Hypotheses must be in terms of \(\rho\), the population correlation coefficient. Edexcel papers print the critical value table in the formula booklet; AQA and OCR usually give the critical value or p-value in the question. OCR may ask for the test to be "carried out" with the p-value supplied from software.
Question 4medium4 marksYear 13
A garden centre records, for 15 randomly chosen days, the maximum temperature and the number of bags of compost sold. The PMCC is 0.48 and software gives the \(p\)-value for a test of \(H_0: \rho = 0\) against \(H_1: \rho \gt 0\) as 0.0351.
(a) Test at the 5% level of significance whether there is positive correlation. (2)
(b) State the conclusion if the test had been carried out at the 1% level. (1)
(c) The manager says "higher temperatures cause more compost to be sold". Comment on this statement. (1)
Mark scheme and answer
(a) \(0.0351 \lt 0.05\) so reject \(H_0\) M1
Evidence of positive correlation between maximum temperature and number of compost bags sold A1
(b) \(0.0351 \gt 0.01\): not significant; insufficient evidence of positive correlation B1
(c) Correlation does not imply causation (e.g. both may depend on season / weekends) B1
Answer: (a) p = 0.0351 < 0.05: evidence of positive correlation; (b) not significant at 1%; (c) correlation ≠ causation
Board notes: Hypotheses must be in terms of \(\rho\), the population correlation coefficient. Edexcel papers print the critical value table in the formula booklet; AQA and OCR usually give the critical value or p-value in the question. OCR may ask for the test to be "carried out" with the p-value supplied from software.
Question 5medium6 marksYear 13
An ecologist believes that the more cars that pass a hedge each hour, the fewer species of bird nest in it. She collects data from 10 randomly chosen hedgerows and finds that the PMCC between hourly traffic count and number of nesting species is \(-0.58\). Critical values for \(n = 10\): 5% one-tailed 0.5494, 2.5% one-tailed 0.6319.
(a) Explain why a one-tailed test is appropriate. (1)
(b) Test, at the 2.5% level, whether there is evidence to support her belief. (4)
(c) State whether the conclusion would change at the 5% level. (1)
Mark scheme and answer
(a) She has a prior belief about the direction of the relationship (negative correlation) B1
(b) \(H_0:\rho=0,\ H_1:\rho\lt 0\) B1
Critical value \(-0.6319\) B1
\(-0.58 \gt -0.6319\): not in critical region M1
Insufficient evidence at 2.5% that more traffic is associated with fewer nesting species A1
(c) Yes: \(-0.58 \lt -0.5494\) so significant at 5% B1
Answer: (a) direction predicted; (b) not significant at 2.5%; (c) significant at 5%
Board notes: Hypotheses must be in terms of \(\rho\), the population correlation coefficient. Edexcel papers print the critical value table in the formula booklet; AQA and OCR usually give the critical value or p-value in the question. OCR may ask for the test to be "carried out" with the p-value supplied from software.
Question 6medium4 marksYear 13
A physics student measures the height, \(h\) m, of a ball thrown upwards at 14 equally spaced times \(t\) s from launch until it lands. She finds the PMCC between \(t\) and \(h\) is 0.04. The critical value for a two-tailed test at the 5% level with \(n = 14\) is 0.5324.
(a) Test at the 5% level whether there is correlation between \(t\) and \(h\). (3)
(b) The student concludes that height does not depend on time. Explain why she is wrong. (1)
Mark scheme and answer
(a) \(H_0:\rho=0,\ H_1:\rho\ne0\) B1
\(0.04 \lt 0.5324\), do not reject \(H_0\): no evidence of (linear) correlation M1A1
(b) The PMCC only measures linear association; \(h\) and \(t\) have a strong (quadratic) non-linear relationship B1
Answer: (a) no evidence of linear correlation; (b) relationship is non-linear (quadratic)
Board notes: Hypotheses must be in terms of \(\rho\), the population correlation coefficient. Edexcel papers print the critical value table in the formula booklet; AQA and OCR usually give the critical value or p-value in the question. OCR may ask for the test to be "carried out" with the p-value supplied from software.
Question 7medium4 marksYear 13
For a random sample of 25 car journeys, the correlation coefficient between average speed and fuel consumption (litres per 100 km) is \(-0.38\). The \(p\)-value for a two-tailed test of \(H_0: \rho = 0\) is 0.0610.
(a) Investigate, at the 10% level of significance, whether there is a linear correlation between average speed and fuel consumption. (3)
(b) Write down the \(p\)-value for a one-tailed test of \(H_0: \rho = 0\) against \(H_1: \rho \lt 0\). (1)
Mark scheme and answer
(a) \(H_0:\rho=0,\ H_1:\rho\ne0\) B1
\(0.0610 \lt 0.10\), reject \(H_0\) M1
Evidence of correlation between average speed and fuel consumption A1
(b) 0.0305 B1
Answer: (a) reject H0 at 10%; (b) 0.0305
Board notes: AQA typically writes "Investigate, at the 10% level of significance, whether ..."; Hypotheses must be in terms of \(\rho\), the population correlation coefficient. Edexcel papers print the critical value table in the formula booklet; AQA and OCR usually give the critical value or p-value in the question. OCR may ask for the test to be "carried out" with the p-value supplied from software.
Question 8hard7 marksYear 13
A biologist records the number, \(N\), of bacteria in a culture at time \(t\) hours on 8 occasions. She calculates \(y = \log_{10} N\). The PMCC between \(t\) and \(y\) is 0.97 and the equation of the regression line of \(y\) on \(t\) is \(y = 0.31 + 0.12t\). The critical value for a one-tailed test at the 1% level with \(n = 8\) is 0.7887.
(a) Test, at the 1% level, whether there is positive correlation between \(t\) and \(y\). (3)
(b) Show that the model can be written as \(N = ab^t\), giving the values of \(a\) and \(b\) to 3 significant figures. (3)
(c) Interpret the value of \(b\) in context. (1)
Mark scheme and answer
(a) \(H_0:\rho=0,\ H_1:\rho\gt 0\) B1
\(0.97 \gt 0.7887\), reject \(H_0\) M1
Evidence of positive correlation between \(t\) and \(\log_{10}N\) A1
(b) \(\log_{10} N = 0.31 + 0.12t \Rightarrow N = 10^{0.31}\times(10^{0.12})^t\) M1
\(a = 2.04\) A1
\(b = 1.32\) A1
(c) The number of bacteria is multiplied by about 1.32 each hour (grows by about 32% per hour) B1
Answer: (a) reject H0: positive correlation; (b) a = 2.04, b = 1.32; (c) ×1.32 per hour
Board notes: Logarithmic transformation of \(y = ab^x\) is in Pure (Exponentials and logarithms) for all boards; Edexcel frequently links it to the correlation test in Paper 3. Hypotheses must be in terms of \(\rho\), the population correlation coefficient. Edexcel papers print the critical value table in the formula booklet; AQA and OCR usually give the critical value or p-value in the question. OCR may ask for the test to be "carried out" with the p-value supplied from software.
Question 9hard3 marksYear 13
A market researcher expects the PMCC between two variables to be about 0.35. Part of a table of critical values for a one-tailed test at the 5% level is given below.
| \(n\) | 20 | 22 | 24 | 26 | 28 |
|---|
| critical value | 0.3783 | 0.3598 | 0.3438 | 0.3297 | 0.3172 |
|---|
(a) Assuming the sample PMCC is 0.35, find the smallest sample size in the table for which there would be evidence, at the 5% level, of positive correlation. (2)
(b) Explain why the critical value decreases as \(n\) increases. (1)
Mark scheme and answer
(a) Need \(0.35 \gt \) critical value M1
\(n = 24\) (critical value 0.3438) A1
(b) With a larger sample, a given value of \(r\) is less likely to arise by chance when \(\rho = 0\), so weaker sample correlation is enough for significance B1
Answer: (a) n = 24; (b) larger samples: less chance variation
Board notes: Hypotheses must be in terms of \(\rho\), the population correlation coefficient. Edexcel papers print the critical value table in the formula booklet; AQA and OCR usually give the critical value or p-value in the question. OCR may ask for the test to be "carried out" with the p-value supplied from software.
Question 10hard5 marksYear 13
A dietitian records the daily sugar intake and the body mass index of 11 randomly chosen adults. The PMCC is 0.21. One adult's data point is found to be a recording error and is removed; the PMCC for the remaining 10 adults is 0.74. One-tailed 5% critical values: \(n=11\): 0.5214; \(n=10\): 0.5494.
(a) Test, at the 5% level, for positive correlation using (i) all 11 adults, (ii) the 10 remaining adults. (4)
(b) Comment on the effect of the error on the analysis. (1)
Mark scheme and answer
(a) \(H_0:\rho=0,\ H_1:\rho\gt 0\) B1
(i) \(0.21 \lt 0.5214\): not significant M1A1
(ii) \(0.74 \gt 0.5494\): significant, evidence of positive correlation A1
(b) A single erroneous point (outlier) greatly reduced \(r\) and changed the conclusion; data should be cleaned before testing B1
Answer: (a)(i) not significant (ii) significant; (b) outlier changes conclusion
Board notes: Hypotheses must be in terms of \(\rho\), the population correlation coefficient. Edexcel papers print the critical value table in the formula booklet; AQA and OCR usually give the critical value or p-value in the question. OCR may ask for the test to be "carried out" with the p-value supplied from software.
Question 11hard6 marksYear 13
An electricity supplier collects data from 12 homes on floor area, \(x\) m², and mean monthly electricity cost, \(£y\). The values of \(x\) range from 55 to 160. The regression line of \(y\) on \(x\) is \(y = 4.2 + 0.85x\) and the PMCC is 0.91. The critical value for a one-tailed test at the 0.5% level with \(n = 12\) is 0.7079.
(a) Test, at the 0.5% significance level, whether there is positive correlation between floor area and monthly cost. (3)
(b) Interpret the gradient of the regression line. (1)
(c) Estimate the monthly cost for a flat of floor area 30 m², and comment on the reliability of your estimate. (2)
Mark scheme and answer
(a) \(H_0:\rho=0,\ H_1:\rho\gt 0\) B1
\(0.91 \gt 0.7079\), reject \(H_0\) M1
Strong evidence of positive correlation between floor area and monthly electricity cost A1
(b) Each extra 1 m² of floor area is associated with an extra £0.85 per month in electricity cost B1
(c) \(y = 4.2 + 0.85\times30 = 29.70\), i.e. £29.70 B1
Unreliable: extrapolation, 30 is outside the range 55 to 160 B1
Answer: (a) reject H0; (b) +£0.85 per extra m²; (c) £29.70, unreliable (extrapolation)
Board notes: Hypotheses must be in terms of \(\rho\), the population correlation coefficient. Edexcel papers print the critical value table in the formula booklet; AQA and OCR usually give the critical value or p-value in the question. OCR may ask for the test to be "carried out" with the p-value supplied from software.
Question 12challenging3 marksYear 13
Two researchers each test \(H_0: \rho = 0\) against \(H_1: \rho \gt 0\) using the same sample of 18 pairs of data. Researcher A uses a 5% significance level and Researcher B uses a 1% significance level. For \(n = 18\) the one-tailed critical values are 0.4000 (5%) and 0.5425 (1%).
(a) Find the range of values of the sample PMCC, \(r\), for which the researchers reach different conclusions. (2)
(b) Researcher B says "Using 1% means I am less likely to wrongly claim there is correlation." Explain whether she is correct. (1)
Mark scheme and answer
(a) A rejects if \(r \gt 0.4000\); B rejects if \(r \gt 0.5425\) M1
\(0.4000 \lt r \le 0.5425\) A1 (accept \(\lt\) or \(\le\) at either end)
(b) Correct: the significance level is the probability of rejecting \(H_0\) when it is true, so 1% gives a smaller chance of wrongly concluding correlation exists B1
Answer: (a) 0.4000 < r ≤ 0.5425; (b) correct
Board notes: Hypotheses must be in terms of \(\rho\), the population correlation coefficient. Edexcel papers print the critical value table in the formula booklet; AQA and OCR usually give the critical value or p-value in the question. OCR may ask for the test to be "carried out" with the p-value supplied from software.
Original questions in the style of Edexcel 9MA0, independently checked before publishing. Not past-paper questions. Covers: One-tailed test with critical value, Language of correlation tests, Two-tailed test with critical value, Test using a p-value, Interpreting correlation, Correlation with logarithmic transformation, Critical values and sample size, Effect of outliers, Regression and correlation.