Edexcel IAL P4 Proof: Exam Questions and Answers
Proof by contradiction (e.g. irrationality of √2, infinitely many primes).
- P4 · Pure Mathematics 4
- Calculator allowed
- 13 practice questions
- Tested in 3 of the last 4 papers
What the questions test
The 13 P4 proof practice questions cover:
Worked example 1
Prove by contradiction that there are infinitely many prime numbers.
Mark scheme
- M1 for assuming that there is a finite number of prime numbers, listing them as
. - M1 for constructing a new number
. - M1 for arguing that dividing
by any of the primes leaves a remainder of , meaning has no prime factors from the finite list. - A1 for concluding that
must either be a new prime itself or have a prime factor not in the list, contradicting the assumption that the list contains all primes.
Worked example 2
Prove by contradiction that if
Mark scheme
- M1 for assuming that there exist integers
and such that , which rearranges to . - M1 for deducing that since
is an even number, must also be an even number. - M1 for letting
, substituting to get , and dividing by to get . - A1 for observing that the left-hand side
is even while the right-hand side is odd, which is a contradiction, so .
Common P4 proof mistakes
- Proof by contradiction: the assumption and conclusion. Begin "Assume, for contradiction, that …" (including any domain), reach a contradiction, state it and conclude.
See it go wrong, then right
Wrong: Assume there is an even number. Then n + 2 is even. So there is no largest.
Right: Assume, for contradiction, that there is a largest even number, N.
N + 2 is even (N = 2k ⇒ N + 2 = 2(k + 1)) and N + 2 > N.
This contradicts N being the largest even number.
So there is no largest even number.
Try it now
1 of 5
- Question 1 of 5
- Question 2 of 5
- Question 3 of 5
- Question 4 of 5
- Question 5 of 5
5 quick questions on proof by contradiction. No sign-in needed.
FAQ
What proof is in Edexcel IAL P4?
Proof by contradiction (e.g. irrationality of √2, infinitely many primes).
Is P4 a calculator paper?
Yes, a calculator is allowed in P4, but method marks are only given for working you write down.
How are P4 proof questions marked?
With M marks for a correct method, A marks for accurate answers that depend on the M mark before them, and B marks for independent results, as in the worked examples on this page.
How often does proof come up in P4?
In our mapping of the 4 Pearson P4 papers from June 2024 to June 2025, proof was tested in 3 of them (3 questions in all). Any topic can be examined in any series.
What are the common mistakes in P4 proof?
Proof by contradiction: the assumption and conclusion. Each one is explained on this page, with how to avoid it.
P4 past papers
Official Pearson P4 papers and mark schemes, with a timer: all IAL P4 past papers. Most recent: June 2025 · January 2025 · October 2024 · June 2024.
Your P4 revision kit
- P4 Proof notesThe topic in plain English, with the key formulas and worked examples.
- P4 formulas (free PDF)The IAL formulas on one page, with the ones the Pearson booklet leaves out marked.
- P4 past papersPearson's own papers and mark schemes by series, with an exam timer.
- Calculator guideKeystrokes for the exam calculator skills. A calculator is allowed in every IAL unit, P4 included.
Save your P4 answers and track your progressA free account remembers the questions you have done and brings you back to this page.
Join freeAlready have an account? Sign in
Applying for maths, computer science or economics? TMUA practice on this topic: Types of proof and counterexamples · Errors in purported proofs. TMUA preparation: notes, questions and mock papers →
More P4 topics
- Knowledge organiser: Pure Mathematics 4 (P4) on one page (printable)