TMUA: Errors in purported proofs
Paper 2: identifying errors in purported proofs.
- Section 2 (Paper 2) · Err1-Err2 Identifying errors in proofs · spec Err1-Err2
- Paper 2 only
- 18 free questions
- No calculator
What the specification covers
- Dividing by something that may be zero (ab = ac does not give b = c)
- sin A = sin B does not give A = B; squaring both sides creates extra roots
- Assuming the result, or checking only one direction of an 'if and only if'
Key ideas
- Dividing by a quantity that might be zero loses solutions (from
you cannot conclude ). - Squaring both sides can introduce solutions that do not satisfy the original equation.
- From
you get ; taking only the positive root loses a solution. - Multiplying an inequality by an expression of unknown sign is invalid;
does not give .
Common mistakes
- The first invalid step is the answer, even if later steps are also wrong.
- A correct final answer does not make every step valid.
Exam tip
Check each step: does it follow from the previous one for every value allowed?
Worked example
Worked example
A student solves
(1)
(2) Divide both sides by
(3) Take square roots:
Which of the following is true?
- A solution is lost at step (2) only.
- A solution is lost at step (3) only.
- Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).
- The working is correct and complete.
- An incorrect solution is introduced at step (3).
Answer: C: Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).
The full solution set is
Practice questions
Try each question before opening the solution. No calculator: the TMUA does not allow one. Every answer here was checked independently before it was published, and each solution ends with the fastest reliable method.
Question 1
A student solves
- The answer misses some solutions and includes no wrong values
- The answer misses some solutions and includes some wrong values
- The answer includes some values that are not solutions
- The answer is correct
- There are no solutions
Show the answer and solution
Answer: A: The answer misses some solutions and includes no wrong values
Multiplying by
Question 2
Claim: if
'Proof': (1) Since
Which of the following is true?
- The claim is true but step (1) is invalid.
- The claim is true and the proof is correct.
- The claim is false, and the first invalid step is (2).
- The claim is false, and the first invalid step is (1).
- The claim is false, and the first invalid step is (3).
Show the answer and solution
Answer: D: The claim is false, and the first invalid step is (1).
The claim is false:
Question 3
A student claims that
- There is no counterexample
Show the answer and solution
Answer: A:
Question 4
A student solves an equation as follows.
(1)
(2) Divide both sides by
(3) Take square roots:
Which of the following is true?
- An incorrect solution is introduced at step (3).
- A solution is lost at step (3) only.
- Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).
- A solution is lost at step (2) only.
- The working is correct and complete.
Show the answer and solution
Answer: C: Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).
The full solution set is
Question 5
A student solves an equation as follows.
(1)
(2) Divide both sides by
(3) So
Which of the following is true?
- The working is correct and complete.
- A solution is lost at step (2) only.
- Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).
- An incorrect solution is introduced at step (3).
- A solution is lost at step (3) only.
Show the answer and solution
Answer: B: A solution is lost at step (2) only.
The full solution set is
Question 6
A student solves an equation as follows.
(1)
(2) Divide both sides by
(3) So
Which of the following is true?
- A solution is lost at step (2) only.
- Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).
- A solution is lost at step (3) only.
- The working is correct and complete.
- An incorrect solution is introduced at step (3).
Show the answer and solution
Answer: A: A solution is lost at step (2) only.
The full solution set is
Question 7
A student solves an equation as follows.
(1)
(2) Divide both sides by
(3) So
Which of the following is true?
- A solution is lost at step (2) only.
- Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).
- An incorrect solution is introduced at step (3).
- The working is correct and complete.
- A solution is lost at step (3) only.
Show the answer and solution
Answer: A: A solution is lost at step (2) only.
The full solution set is
Question 8
A student solves an equation as follows.
(1)
(2) Divide both sides by
(3) Take square roots:
Which of the following is true?
- An incorrect solution is introduced at step (3).
- The working is correct and complete.
- A solution is lost at step (3) only.
- Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).
- A solution is lost at step (2) only.
Show the answer and solution
Answer: D: Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).
The full solution set is
Question 9
A student solves an equation as follows.
(1)
(2) Divide both sides by
(3) Take square roots:
Which of the following is true?
- A solution is lost at step (2) only.
- The working is correct and complete.
- A solution is lost at step (3) only.
- An incorrect solution is introduced at step (3).
- Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).
Show the answer and solution
Answer: E: Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).
The full solution set is
Question 10
A student solves an equation as follows.
(1)
(2) Divide both sides by
(3) So
Which of the following is true?
- Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).
- The working is correct and complete.
- A solution is lost at step (2) only.
- A solution is lost at step (3) only.
- An incorrect solution is introduced at step (3).
Show the answer and solution
Answer: C: A solution is lost at step (2) only.
The full solution set is
Question 11
A student solves an equation as follows.
(1)
(2) Divide both sides by
(3) So
Which of the following is true?
- An incorrect solution is introduced at step (3).
- The working is correct and complete.
- Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).
- A solution is lost at step (3) only.
- A solution is lost at step (2) only.
Show the answer and solution
Answer: E: A solution is lost at step (2) only.
The full solution set is
Question 12
A student solves
- Both
and are solutions. - Neither
nor is a solution. is a solution and is not.- The equation has more than two solutions.
is a solution and is not.
Show the answer and solution
Answer: E:
Squaring is not reversible: it also solves
Fast method: The right-hand side
Question 13
A student solves
is a solution and is not. is a solution and is not.- The equation has more than two solutions.
- Both
and are solutions. - Neither
nor is a solution.
Show the answer and solution
Answer: B:
Squaring is not reversible: it also solves
Fast method: The right-hand side
Question 14
A student writes the following lines when solving an equation.
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
Which is the first line whose solution set is different from that of the line before it?
- Line (4)
- Line (3)
- None: every line has exactly the same solutions as the line before it.
- Line (5)
- Line (2)
Show the answer and solution
Answer: C: None: every line has exactly the same solutions as the line before it.
Check each move: is it reversible for every allowed
Fast method: Scan for the irreversible moves (divide by something with
Question 15
A student writes the following lines when solving an equation.
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
Which is the first line whose solution set is different from that of the line before it?
- Line (3)
- Line (2)
- Line (5)
- Line (4)
- None: every line has exactly the same solutions as the line before it.
Show the answer and solution
Answer: D: Line (4)
Check each move: is it reversible for every allowed
Fast method: Scan for the irreversible moves (divide by something with
Question 16
In each statement below,
I If
II If
III If
- I only
- II only
- none of them
- I and II only
- III only
- I, II and III
Show the answer and solution
Answer: A: I only
A deduction is valid only if it holds for every pair
Fast method: Squares, moduli, products and reciprocals are where deductions break, and the answer can change with the allowed numbers: try a negative number, zero and a number between 0 and 1 when they are allowed.
Question 17
In each statement below,
I If
II If
III If
- I only
- III only
- I and III only
- II and III only
- II only
- I and II only
Show the answer and solution
Answer: E: II only
A deduction is valid only if it holds for every pair
Fast method: Squares, moduli, products and reciprocals are where deductions break, and the answer can change with the allowed numbers: try a negative number, zero and a number between 0 and 1 when they are allowed.
38 more errors in purported proofs questions
Each with a full worked solution and a fast-method note. They also appear in topic drills, spaced review and mock papers 3 to 10.
Keep going
The next topic in the specification: notes, a worked example and free questions.
Next: Indices and surdsTMUA is run by UAT-UK. A Level Math Revision is independent: it is not affiliated with or endorsed by UAT-UK, Pearson VUE or any university. Every question here is our own.