Skip to main content

TMUA: Errors in purported proofs

Paper 2: identifying errors in purported proofs.

Practise errors in purported proofs →Drill this topic

What the specification covers

Key ideas

Common mistakes

Exam tip

Check each step: does it follow from the previous one for every value allowed?

Worked example

Worked example

A student solves x3=4x as follows.
(1) x3=4x
(2) Divide both sides by x: x2=4
(3) Take square roots: x=2
Which of the following is true?

  1. A solution is lost at step (2) only.
  2. A solution is lost at step (3) only.
  3. Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).
  4. The working is correct and complete.
  5. An incorrect solution is introduced at step (3).

Answer: C: Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).

The full solution set is {−2,0,2}. Dividing by x assumes x≠0, losing x=0 at step (2). From x2=4, x=±2, so step (3) loses x=−2.

Practice questions

Try each question before opening the solution. No calculator: the TMUA does not allow one. Every answer here was checked independently before it was published, and each solution ends with the fastest reliable method.

Question 1

A student solves 1x−1<2 by multiplying both sides by x−1 to get 1<2(x−1), and concludes that the solution is x>32. Which of the following is true?

  1. The answer misses some solutions and includes no wrong values
  2. The answer misses some solutions and includes some wrong values
  3. The answer includes some values that are not solutions
  4. The answer is correct
  5. There are no solutions
Show the answer and solution

Answer: A: The answer misses some solutions and includes no wrong values

Multiplying by x−1 is only valid when x−1>0. For x<1, the left side is negative, so 1x−1<2 holds too. The true solution is x<1 or x>32. Every x>32 is a genuine solution, so the student's answer misses x<1 and includes nothing wrong.

Question 2

Claim: if a and b are real numbers with a>b, then a2>b2.
'Proof': (1) Since a>b, multiplying by a gives a2>ab. (2) Since a>b, multiplying by b gives ab>b2. (3) So a2>ab>b2.
Which of the following is true?

  1. The claim is true but step (1) is invalid.
  2. The claim is true and the proof is correct.
  3. The claim is false, and the first invalid step is (2).
  4. The claim is false, and the first invalid step is (1).
  5. The claim is false, and the first invalid step is (3).
Show the answer and solution

Answer: D: The claim is false, and the first invalid step is (1).

The claim is false: a=1, b=−2 gives 1<4. Step (1) multiplies an inequality by a, valid only for a>0: with a=−1, b=−2 it would say 1>2. So step (1) is the first invalid step (step (3) correctly combines (1) and (2)).

Question 3

A student claims that 2n>n2 for every positive integer n, having checked n=1 and n=5. What is the smallest counterexample?

  1. n=2
  2. n=4
  3. There is no counterexample
  4. n=6
  5. n=3
Show the answer and solution

Answer: A: n=2

n=2: 4>4 is false, so n=2 is a counterexample (n=3: 8<9 and n=4: 16=16 fail too; n=1 works).

Question 4

A student solves an equation as follows.
(1) x3=9x
(2) Divide both sides by x: x2=9
(3) Take square roots: x=3
Which of the following is true?

  1. An incorrect solution is introduced at step (3).
  2. A solution is lost at step (3) only.
  3. Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).
  4. A solution is lost at step (2) only.
  5. The working is correct and complete.
Show the answer and solution

Answer: C: Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).

The full solution set is {−3,0,3}. Dividing by x loses x=0 at step (2); from x2=9, x=±3, so step (3) loses x=−3.

Question 5

A student solves an equation as follows.
(1) (x−3)(x+1)=3(x−3)
(2) Divide both sides by (x−3): x+1=3
(3) So x=2
Which of the following is true?

  1. The working is correct and complete.
  2. A solution is lost at step (2) only.
  3. Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).
  4. An incorrect solution is introduced at step (3).
  5. A solution is lost at step (3) only.
Show the answer and solution

Answer: B: A solution is lost at step (2) only.

The full solution set is {3,2}. Dividing by x−3 assumes x≠3, losing x=3 at step (2); step (3) is correct.

Question 6

A student solves an equation as follows.
(1) (x−4)(x+5)=3(x−4)
(2) Divide both sides by (x−4): x+5=3
(3) So x=−2
Which of the following is true?

  1. A solution is lost at step (2) only.
  2. Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).
  3. A solution is lost at step (3) only.
  4. The working is correct and complete.
  5. An incorrect solution is introduced at step (3).
Show the answer and solution

Answer: A: A solution is lost at step (2) only.

The full solution set is {4,−2}. Dividing by x−4 assumes x≠4, losing x=4 at step (2); step (3) is correct.

Question 7

A student solves an equation as follows.
(1) (x−1)(x+4)=2(x−1)
(2) Divide both sides by (x−1): x+4=2
(3) So x=−2
Which of the following is true?

  1. A solution is lost at step (2) only.
  2. Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).
  3. An incorrect solution is introduced at step (3).
  4. The working is correct and complete.
  5. A solution is lost at step (3) only.
Show the answer and solution

Answer: A: A solution is lost at step (2) only.

The full solution set is {1,−2}. Dividing by x−1 assumes x≠1, losing x=1 at step (2); step (3) is correct.

Question 8

A student solves an equation as follows.
(1) x3=16x
(2) Divide both sides by x: x2=16
(3) Take square roots: x=4
Which of the following is true?

  1. An incorrect solution is introduced at step (3).
  2. The working is correct and complete.
  3. A solution is lost at step (3) only.
  4. Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).
  5. A solution is lost at step (2) only.
Show the answer and solution

Answer: D: Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).

The full solution set is {−4,0,4}. Dividing by x loses x=0 at step (2); from x2=16, x=±4, so step (3) loses x=−4.

Question 9

A student solves an equation as follows.
(1) x3=36x
(2) Divide both sides by x: x2=36
(3) Take square roots: x=6
Which of the following is true?

  1. A solution is lost at step (2) only.
  2. The working is correct and complete.
  3. A solution is lost at step (3) only.
  4. An incorrect solution is introduced at step (3).
  5. Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).
Show the answer and solution

Answer: E: Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).

The full solution set is {−6,0,6}. Dividing by x loses x=0 at step (2); from x2=36, x=±6, so step (3) loses x=−6.

Question 10

A student solves an equation as follows.
(1) (x−2)(x+3)=6(x−2)
(2) Divide both sides by (x−2): x+3=6
(3) So x=3
Which of the following is true?

  1. Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).
  2. The working is correct and complete.
  3. A solution is lost at step (2) only.
  4. A solution is lost at step (3) only.
  5. An incorrect solution is introduced at step (3).
Show the answer and solution

Answer: C: A solution is lost at step (2) only.

The full solution set is {2,3}. Dividing by x−2 assumes x≠2, losing x=2 at step (2); step (3) is correct.

Question 11

A student solves an equation as follows.
(1) (x−2)(x+3)=3(x−2)
(2) Divide both sides by (x−2): x+3=3
(3) So x=0
Which of the following is true?

  1. An incorrect solution is introduced at step (3).
  2. The working is correct and complete.
  3. Solutions are lost at both step (2) and step (3).
  4. A solution is lost at step (3) only.
  5. A solution is lost at step (2) only.
Show the answer and solution

Answer: E: A solution is lost at step (2) only.

The full solution set is {2,0}. Dividing by x−2 assumes x≠2, losing x=2 at step (2); step (3) is correct.

Question 12

A student solves x+58=x+2 by squaring both sides, which gives x+58=(x+2)2, then x2+3x−54=0, so x=6 or x=−9. Which of the following is true?

  1. Both x=6 and x=−9 are solutions.
  2. Neither x=6 nor x=−9 is a solution.
  3. x=−9 is a solution and x=6 is not.
  4. The equation has more than two solutions.
  5. x=6 is a solution and x=−9 is not.
Show the answer and solution

Answer: E: x=6 is a solution and x=−9 is not.

Squaring is not reversible: it also solves −x+58=x+2. Check both values in the original equation. x=6: 64=8 and 6+2=8, equal. x=−9: 49=7 but −9+2=−7<0, and a square root is never negative. So only x=6 is a solution.

Fast method: The right-hand side x+2 must be ≥0, because a square root is never negative. That alone rules out x=−9.

Question 13

A student solves x+52=x−4 by squaring both sides, which gives x+52=(x−4)2, then x2−9x−36=0, so x=12 or x=−3. Which of the following is true?

  1. x=−3 is a solution and x=12 is not.
  2. x=12 is a solution and x=−3 is not.
  3. The equation has more than two solutions.
  4. Both x=12 and x=−3 are solutions.
  5. Neither x=12 nor x=−3 is a solution.
Show the answer and solution

Answer: B: x=12 is a solution and x=−3 is not.

Squaring is not reversible: it also solves −x+52=x−4. Check both values in the original equation. x=12: 64=8 and 12−4=8, equal. x=−3: 49=7 but −3−4=−7<0, and a square root is never negative. So only x=12 is a solution.

Fast method: The right-hand side x−4 must be ≥0, because a square root is never negative. That alone rules out x=−3.

Question 14

A student writes the following lines when solving an equation.
(1) x2+1x=20
(2) x2+1x−20=0
(3) (x−4)(x+5)=0
(4) x−4=0 or x+5=0
(5) x=4 or x=−5
Which is the first line whose solution set is different from that of the line before it?

  1. Line (4)
  2. Line (3)
  3. None: every line has exactly the same solutions as the line before it.
  4. Line (5)
  5. Line (2)
Show the answer and solution

Answer: C: None: every line has exactly the same solutions as the line before it.

Check each move: is it reversible for every allowed x? Dividing by an expression that can be zero, square-rooting without ±, squaring, and removing a modulus are the usual suspects. Each line is an equivalent rearrangement or factorisation, so no solution is lost or gained.

Fast method: Scan for the irreversible moves (divide by something with x in it, square, square-root, drop a modulus) and test only those lines.

Question 15

A student writes the following lines when solving an equation.
(1) x3=4x
(2) x3−4x=0
(3) x(x2−4)=0
(4) x2−4=0
(5) x=2
Which is the first line whose solution set is different from that of the line before it?

  1. Line (3)
  2. Line (2)
  3. Line (5)
  4. Line (4)
  5. None: every line has exactly the same solutions as the line before it.
Show the answer and solution

Answer: D: Line (4)

Check each move: is it reversible for every allowed x? Dividing by an expression that can be zero, square-rooting without ±, squaring, and removing a modulus are the usual suspects. Line (4) divides by x, losing x=0.

Fast method: Scan for the irreversible moves (divide by something with x in it, square, square-root, drop a modulus) and test only those lines.

Question 16

In each statement below, a and b are non-zero real numbers. Which of the deductions are valid?
I   If a=b, then a2=b2
II   If ab>0, then a>0
III   If a>b, then ab>b2

  1. I only
  2. II only
  3. none of them
  4. I and II only
  5. III only
  6. I, II and III
Show the answer and solution

Answer: A: I only

A deduction is valid only if it holds for every pair a, b of non-zero real numbers; one counterexample shows it is invalid. I (if a=b, then a2=b2) is valid. II (if ab>0, then a>0) is not valid: a=−4, b=−4 is a counterexample. III (if a>b, then ab>b2) is not valid: a=−72, b=−4 is a counterexample.

Fast method: Squares, moduli, products and reciprocals are where deductions break, and the answer can change with the allowed numbers: try a negative number, zero and a number between 0 and 1 when they are allowed.

Question 17

In each statement below, a and b are negative real numbers. Which of the deductions are valid?
I   If a>b, then |a|>|b|
II   If a>|b|, then a>b
III   If a>b, then a2>b2

  1. I only
  2. III only
  3. I and III only
  4. II and III only
  5. II only
  6. I and II only
Show the answer and solution

Answer: E: II only

A deduction is valid only if it holds for every pair a, b of negative real numbers; one counterexample shows it is invalid. I (if a>b, then |a|>|b|) is not valid: a=−72, b=−4 is a counterexample. II (if a>|b|, then a>b) is valid. III (if a>b, then a2>b2) is not valid: a=−72, b=−4 is a counterexample.

Fast method: Squares, moduli, products and reciprocals are where deductions break, and the answer can change with the allowed numbers: try a negative number, zero and a number between 0 and 1 when they are allowed.

38 more errors in purported proofs questions

Each with a full worked solution and a fast-method note. They also appear in topic drills, spaced review and mock papers 3 to 10.

Included with A Level plans, and with IB, IGCSE or CBSE plans.

Keep going

The next topic in the specification: notes, a worked example and free questions.

Next: Indices and surds

Previous: Deductions, conjectures and ordering proofs · Drill errors in purported proofs · Free TMUA mock paper 1 · Timed practice paper · TMUA Paper 2: logic and proof · A Level Maths: Proof

TMUA is run by UAT-UK. A Level Math Revision is independent: it is not affiliated with or endorsed by UAT-UK, Pearson VUE or any university. Every question here is our own.